What was the real reason the US government banned Huawei?

wa
9

Were you jealous of China's rise? About Huawei defeating their baby Apple?

Me

The United States wants to control and monitor everything in the world itself, but the Huawei group refuses to provide the US secret service with an interface for surveillance.

De

Sorry but that's nonsense. The reason is that, according to the US government, Huawei does offer interfaces to the secret services - but of course to the Chinese secret services. There's no solid evidence for this, but Trump is sufficient as an excuse.

But when it comes to surveillance in general, China really is not lagging behind the United States.

st

"Very well, there's no solid evidence for this"

Well, the word and this sentence already say everything.

Without concrete evidence, but only conjectures, then one should understand the allegation against Huawei as a kind of defamation, right?

https://de.wikipedia.org/...svermutung

st

Here too:

The presumption of guilt (in dubio contra reum) is a presumption of law and is always present when the specific guilt / responsibility of a person has not yet been determined, but is deemed to be probable by law (de iure) (however, there are still doubts about the deed or action] or execution) and this goes far beyond suspicion or suspicion.

The presumption of guilt is to be seen as a contrast to the well-known and legally recognized presumption of innocence.

While the presumption of innocence is considered one of the basic principles of constitutional and administrative criminal and criminal tax law (a very important sentence), the presumption of guilt is lawfully used in many areas of state procedural law.

https://de.wikipedia.org/...dvermutung

De

I did not condemn Huawei here, I only mentioned the (advanced) reasons of the US government. Huawei is certainly not an innocent lamb, but the espionage accusations have not been proven.

st

Why? One of the main causes is very clear: to eliminate competition

Because Huawei has already become too powerful:

In Europe there are Ericsson or Nokia, both of which produce modern transmitter systems, but also partly in China.

However, experts assume that a major Huawei boycott in several countries would probably not enable the two companies to meet the replacement needs in a short time.

Samsung from South Korea produces network infrastructure, but is rather a small player in this area overall.

From the United States, Cisco is active in the industry. However, the company focuses less on mobile communications and more on the equipment of company networks:

https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/huawei-5g-usa-101.html

Ericsson and Noka could not replace Huawei:

https://www.golem.de/news/netzbetreiber-ericsson-und-nokia-koennten-huawei-nicht-ersetzen-1902-139431.html

In addition, Nokia or Ericsson are technically at least two years behind, as experts estimate.

In addition, Huawei holds around 80 percent of all patents for 5G technology:

https://www.zeit.de/2019/09/huawei-mobiles-internet-5g-china-spionageverdacht-konzern

Another news about Huawei 3 years ago:

Most patent applications in Europe came from a Chinese manufacturer (Huawei) in 2017 - for the first time in the history of the European Patent Office:

https://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/patentanmeldungen-huawei-vor-europaeern-1.3896053

Em

Naturally.

The United States does not like to see China go past them economically, militarily and politically to the top of the world or have already migrated.

What does a childlike or simply knitted creature like Trump do about it? Of course, you try to put some stones in the way of the Chinese. Knowing that you don't force the big kite out of business, but rather strengthens it sustainably. But you do it anyway.

wa

If I'm not wrong, Huawei has overtaken Apple as the second largest smartphone manufacturer in the world?

Gu

1.) Huawei undermined the Iran embargo

2.) Huawei builds mobile infrastructure. Since all Chinese companies are absolutely loyal to the government and everyone wants to lick up Xi's spit there, many see the danger that Huawei will build back doors into the hardware to collect data.

It has nothing to do with cell phones. The comparison to Apple comes from people who don't understand the market at all.